America, Cars, and Computers: Lee Fang
 @lhfang
 When robotics/driverless cars replace 1/3
 jobs in America, and the political
 establishment does nothing, 2016 anger
 will look minuscule.
 11/5/16, 10:03 PM
 287 RETWEETS 497 LIKES
cracked-pearl-78:
c-bassmeow:

Shit

Luddites have been making this claim since the Industrial Revolution and they are no closer to being true.

While you are historically correct, many economists, tech experts (people who work with tech who are far from luddites), and even CEO’s of tech companies believe that with the increasing automation  of jobs, many jobs will go to machines and there will be a great, massive reduction in jobs. Economists both from the left and right think this is to be true since it’s already happening just not to a large extent YET. Even the Bureau of labor statistics projects massive job loss due to human jobs becoming obsolete because  technological changes that make it more efficient to replace humans with machines/computers since it will be cheaper, less error, and more efficient to replace humans since machines do not need to rest, do not have families, can be worked to their extreme, and can be programmed to do something correctly all the time. Moreover with the prospect of artificial intelligence which is being invested heavily, the change might manifest more rapidly. One remedy for this from some economists from both the left and right is to enact a universal basic income. But while I appreciate your skepticism, which is very healthy because i too have a disdain for predictions with no basis in reality or that sound alarmist- to my knowledge there seems to be a slow, growing consensus from many fields that technological progress will replace many many human jobs the extent to which they will replace them is obviously debatable but the fact that they will be replaced to some degree that affects us seems to not be. I’m sorry I can’t cite sources I’m on my phone at the moment.Also,  throughout history technological progress has always replaced jobs.  There are less shoemakers now, farmers, cashiers, and countless other positions due to technological progress. Historically though,  we have been able to replace these jobs with new ones created through social change, technological change, and other factors but I and many think that we have hit a special time in history where technology will simply take over many more jobs than we can replace.  Technological progress is so advanced now that many products that we had to buy separately are now consolidated into one (an iphone is a fax machine, a phone, a computer, a camera, a tv, etc) and at times less people are needed in the aggregate to make these products.  Lastly, and this is just semantics,  I do believe that many techno-optimists believe technological progress automatically means “good” because we associate the word technology with human advancement and because “progress” is  a word that assumes benevolence, but this is not the case. Technological and scientific progress are not inherently good.  I am no luddite and I am a lover of science BUT science and technological advancement are sometimes removed and unaware of the unintended consequences created by their advancement since we rarely know all the social, economic,  political, ramifications brought by said technology/scientific discoveries at the time of their creation and birth. So to assume everything will be a positive step forward is a naive assumption not supported by data but simply a subjective feeling of comfort and happiness because tech progress is being made. So i am no luddite, but I do think there is cause this time to be healthily afraid of what is to come.  A capitalist system has historically relied on humans but when those who own the means of production switch to a more inexpensive, rational, hard working, and anti-error prone substitute …. then what happens? It has never been done before so to assume you can use history as a guide (which is usually a very intelligent move) is somewhat misguided for what is to come has never happened before. 

cracked-pearl-78: c-bassmeow: Shit Luddites have been making this claim since the Industrial Revolution and they are no closer to being true. While you are historically correct, many economists, tech experts (people who work with tech who are far from luddites), and even CEO’s of tech companies believe that with the increasing automation  of jobs, many jobs will go to machines and there will be a great, massive reduction in jobs. Economists both from the left and right think this is to be true since it’s already happening just not to a large extent YET. Even the Bureau of labor statistics projects massive job loss due to human jobs becoming obsolete because technological changes that make it more efficient to replace humans with machines/computers since it will be cheaper, less error, and more efficient to replace humans since machines do not need to rest, do not have families, can be worked to their extreme, and can be programmed to do something correctly all the time. Moreover with the prospect of artificial intelligence which is being invested heavily, the change might manifest more rapidly. One remedy for this from some economists from both the left and right is to enact a universal basic income. But while I appreciate your skepticism, which is very healthy because i too have a disdain for predictions with no basis in reality or that sound alarmist- to my knowledge there seems to be a slow, growing consensus from many fields that technological progress will replace many many human jobs the extent to which they will replace them is obviously debatable but the fact that they will be replaced to some degree that affects us seems to not be. I’m sorry I can’t cite sources I’m on my phone at the moment.Also,  throughout history technological progress has always replaced jobs.  There are less shoemakers now, farmers, cashiers, and countless other positions due to technological progress. Historically though,  we have been able to replace these jobs with new ones created through social change, technological change, and other factors but I and many think that we have hit a special time in history where technology will simply take over many more jobs than we can replace.  Technological progress is so advanced now that many products that we had to buy separately are now consolidated into one (an iphone is a fax machine, a phone, a computer, a camera, a tv, etc) and at times less people are needed in the aggregate to make these products.  Lastly, and this is just semantics,  I do believe that many techno-optimists believe technological progress automatically means “good” because we associate the word technology with human advancement and because “progress” is  a word that assumes benevolence, but this is not the case. Technological and scientific progress are not inherently good.  I am no luddite and I am a lover of science BUT science and technological advancement are sometimes removed and unaware of the unintended consequences created by their advancement since we rarely know all the social, economic, political, ramifications brought by said technology/scientific discoveries at the time of their creation and birth. So to assume everything will be a positive step forward is a naive assumption not supported by data but simply a subjective feeling of comfort and happiness because tech progress is being made. So i am no luddite, but I do think there is cause this time to be healthily afraid of what is to come.  A capitalist system has historically relied on humans but when those who own the means of production switch to a more inexpensive, rational, hard working, and anti-error prone substitute …. then what happens? It has never been done before so to assume you can use history as a guide (which is usually a very intelligent move) is somewhat misguided for what is to come has never happened before. 

America
America
cars
cars
Computers
Computers
iphone
iphone
Phone
Phone
shit
shit
Sorry
Sorry
True
True
tumblr
tumblr
Work
Work
Appreciate
Appreciate
Blog
Blog
Camera
Camera
Computer
Computer
Cracked
Cracked
Good
Good
History
History
Http
Http
Jobs
Jobs
Naive
Naive
Revolution
Revolution
Science
Science
Technology
Technology
Time
Time
What Is
What Is
Word
Word
Capitalist
Capitalist
Change
Change
Happiness
Happiness
Industrial Revolution
Industrial Revolution
Knowledge
Knowledge
Never
Never
Reality
Reality
Skepticism
Skepticism
Statistics
Statistics
All The
All The
All the Time
All the Time
Anti
Anti
Artificial
Artificial
Been
Been
rational
rational
job
job
human
human
working
working
rest
rest
com
com
pearl
pearl
step
step
data
data
class
class
who
who
creation
creation
ceo
ceo
can
can
extreme
extreme
artificial intelligence
artificial intelligence
switch
switch
one
one
sound
sound
closer
closer
degree
degree
case
case
fax machine
fax machine
anger
anger
basic
basic
amp
amp
fax
fax
techno
techno
etc
etc
intelligence
intelligence
guide
guide
means
means
believe
believe
lee
lee
will
will
think
think
own
own
them
them
move
move
all
all
projects
projects
make
make
they
they
moment
moment
new
new
you
you
system
system
now
now
luddite
luddite
the time
the time
cite
cite
post
post
birth
birth
what
what
times
times
made
made
for
for
machine
machine
social
social
semantics
semantics
products
products
basis
basis
industrial
industrial
companies
companies
obsolete
obsolete
massive
massive
aggregate
aggregate
reduction
reduction
economic
economic
use
use
href
href
in america
in america
prospect
prospect
happening
happening
scientific
scientific
look
look
income
income
more
more
this
this
political
political
done
done
great
great
right
right
this is
this is
making
making
nothing
nothing
always
always
people
people
humans
humans
likes
likes
disdain
disdain
misguided
misguided
just
just
everything
everything
though
though
then
then
hit
hit
because
because
error
error
afraid
afraid
feeling
feeling
slow
slow
might
might
sometimes
sometimes
happened
happened
those
those
do something
do something
i do
i do
debatable
debatable
hard working
hard working
seems
seems
i can
i can
needed
needed
unaware
unaware
subjective
subjective
assumption
assumption
their
their
go to
go to
separately
separately
usually
usually
assume
assume
efficient
efficient
manifest
manifest
consensus
consensus
my phone
my phone
claim
claim
labor
labor
lover
lover
benevolence
benevolence
there
there
extent
extent
too
too
fact
fact
through
through
positive
 positive
no
 no
/tv/
 /tv/
growing
 growing
something
 something
hard
 hard
need
 need
come
 come
know
 know
left
 left
yet
 yet
said
 said
fang
 fang
large
 large
healthy
 healthy
already
 already
cheaper
 cheaper
changes
 changes
there is
 there is
robotics
 robotics
tumblr blog
 tumblr blog
intelligent
 intelligent
automatically
 automatically
left-and-right
left-and-right
universal-basic-income
universal-basic-income
over
over
special
special
comfort
comfort
Universal
Universal
And
And
The Moment
The Moment
Other
Other
I Am
I Am
Progress
Progress
Loss
Loss
I Am A
I Am A
Both
Both
When
When
Simply
Simply
That
That
The Means Of Production
The Means Of Production
But
But
Not
Not
Tech
Tech
Where
Where
You Are
You Are
Obviously
Obviously
Consequences
Consequences
The
The
The Word
The Word
Not The
Not The
From
From
Sources
Sources
Buy
Buy
Experts
Experts
Correct
Correct
Your
Your
Take
Take
Many
Many
Means Of Production
Means Of Production
Very
Very
Becoming
Becoming
These
These
The Fact That
The Fact That
While
While
Machines
Machines
Fields
Fields
Had To
Had To
Forward
Forward
With
With
Cause
Cause
Advanced
Advanced
Are
Are
Have
Have
Replace
Replace
The Means
The Means
Had
Had
Replaced
Replaced
I Too
I Too
Do Not
Do Not
Also
Also
Manifested
Manifested
Manifesting
Manifesting
Prone
Prone
Farmers
Farmers
Which
Which
Does
Does
Bureau Of Labor Statistics
Bureau Of Labor Statistics
Associate
Associate
Tumblr Com
Tumblr Com
Throughout
Throughout
Since
Since
Bureau
Bureau
Has
Has
Consolidated
Consolidated
Before
Before
Being
Being
Far
Far
Pearles
Pearles
Remedy
Remedy
Simply A
Simply A
Substitute
Substitute
Is Just
Is Just
Positions
Positions
Be True
Be True
Happens
Happens
Economists
Economists
Than
Than
Social Change
Social Change
Inherently
Inherently
Unintended Consequences
Unintended Consequences
Even
Even
Some
Some
Step Forward
Step Forward
Unintended
Unintended
Factors
Factors
Progressing
Progressing
Progression
Progression
Establishment
Establishment
To Assume
To Assume
11 5
11 5
A Word
A Word
Heavily
Heavily
Inexpensive
Inexpensive
Less
Less
Pearling
Pearling
Worked
Worked
1 3
1 3
A Fax Machine
A Fax Machine
A Lover
A Lover
A Phone
A Phone
Affects
Affects
Alarmist
Alarmist
Alarmists
Alarmists
And More
And More
And There
And There
And They Are
And They Are
Automation
Automation
Believe That
Believe That
But I
But I
But The
But The
But When
But When
Faxes
Faxes
For What
For What
Had To Buy
Had To Buy
Have A
Have A
I Appreciate Your
I Appreciate Your
I Do Believe
I Do Believe
In Reality
In Reality
In The
In The
Into
Into
Invested
Invested
Is A
Is A
Is Not
Is Not
Make It
Make It
Need To Rest
Need To Rest
Never Been Done Before
Never Been Done Before
Never Happened
Never Happened
People Are
People Are
People Who
People Who
Predictions
Predictions
Prospecting
Prospecting
Families
Families
To Do
To Do
Able
Able
Advancement
Advancement
At The Moment
At The Moment
Brought
Brought
Correctly
Correctly
Countless
Countless
Creational
Creational
Due
Due
Due To
Due To
Enact
Enact
Enactment
Enactment
Growing Consensus
Growing Consensus
Historically
Historically
Labored
Labored
Laborer
Laborer
Loverly
Loverly
Minuscule
Minuscule
Moreover
Moreover
Ones
Ones
Production
Production
Progressivity
Progressivity
Proneness
Proneness
Prospection
Prospection
Prospective
Prospective
Ramifications
Ramifications
Rapidly
Rapidly
Rarely
Rarely
Removed
Removed
Revolutionize
Revolutionize
Somewhat
Somewhat
Technological
Technological
That Many
That Many
The Industrial Revolution
The Industrial Revolution
The Left
The Left
They Are
They Are
To Be
To Be
Are
Are
Was
Was
After
After
Your
Your
Important
Important
This Is A
This Is A
From
From
The
The
Siblings
Siblings
That
That
Waiting For
Waiting For
When
When
Winners
Winners
And
And
Enjoy
Enjoy
Nationality
Nationality
not-interested
not-interested
out
out
before and after
 before and after
do what u want
 do what u want
screwed up
 screwed up
im serious
 im serious
interested
 interested
must have
 must have
no reason
 no reason
married
 married
already
 already
aging
 aging
others
 others
else
 else
say
 say
follow
 follow
die
 die
no
 no
were
were
comc
comc
i just
i just
i promise
i promise
exam
exam
eyes
eyes
likes
likes
people
people
youre
youre
dead
dead
this
this
for
for
them
them
cigarettes
cigarettes
🤖
🤖
memes
memes
Funny
Funny
Friends
Friends
9gag
9gag
0 to 100
0 to 100
0 to 100
0 to 100
9gag
9gag
Friends
Friends
Funny
Funny
memes
memes
🤖
🤖
cigarettes
cigarettes
them
them
for
for
this
this
dead
dead
youre
youre
people
people
likes
likes
eyes
eyes
exam
exam
i promise
i promise
i just
i just
comc
comc
were
were
no
 no
die
 die
follow
 follow
say
 say
else
 else
others
 others
aging
 aging
already
 already
married
 married
no reason
 no reason
must have
 must have
interested
 interested
im serious
 im serious
screwed up
 screwed up
do what u want
 do what u want
before and after
 before and after
out
out
not-interested
not-interested
Nationality
Nationality
Enjoy
Enjoy
And
And
Winners
Winners
When
When
Waiting For
Waiting For
That
That
Siblings
Siblings
The
The
From
From
This Is A
This Is A
Important
Important
Your
Your
After
After
Was
Was
Are
Are
To Be
To Be
They Are
They Are
The Left
The Left
The Industrial Revolution
The Industrial Revolution
That Many
That Many
Technological
Technological
Somewhat
Somewhat
Revolutionize
Revolutionize
Removed
Removed
Rarely
Rarely
Rapidly
Rapidly
Ramifications
Ramifications
Prospective
Prospective
Prospection
Prospection
Proneness
Proneness
Progressivity
Progressivity
Production
Production
Ones
Ones
Moreover
Moreover
Minuscule
Minuscule
Loverly
Loverly
Laborer
Laborer
Labored
Labored
Historically
Historically
Growing Consensus
Growing Consensus
Enactment
Enactment
Enact
Enact
Due To
Due To
Due
Due
Creational
Creational
Countless
Countless
Correctly
Correctly
Brought
Brought
At The Moment
At The Moment
Advancement
Advancement
Able
Able
To Do
To Do
Families
Families
Prospecting
Prospecting
Predictions
Predictions
People Who
People Who
People Are
People Are
Never Happened
Never Happened
Never Been Done Before
Never Been Done Before
Need To Rest
Need To Rest
Make It
Make It
Is Not
Is Not
Is A
Is A
Invested
Invested
Into
Into
In The
In The
In Reality
In Reality
I Do Believe
I Do Believe
I Appreciate Your
I Appreciate Your
Have A
Have A
Had To Buy
Had To Buy
For What
For What
Faxes
Faxes
But When
But When
But The
But The
But I
But I
Believe That
Believe That
Automation
Automation
And They Are
And They Are
And There
And There
And More
And More
Alarmists
Alarmists
Alarmist
Alarmist
Affects
Affects
A Phone
A Phone
A Lover
A Lover
A Fax Machine
A Fax Machine
1 3
1 3
Worked
Worked
Pearling
Pearling
Less
Less
Inexpensive
Inexpensive
Heavily
Heavily
A Word
A Word
11 5
11 5
To Assume
To Assume
Establishment
Establishment
Progression
Progression
Progressing
Progressing
Factors
Factors
Unintended
Unintended
Step Forward
Step Forward
Some
Some
Even
Even
Unintended Consequences
Unintended Consequences
Inherently
Inherently
Social Change
Social Change
Than
Than
Economists
Economists
Happens
Happens
Be True
Be True
Positions
Positions
Is Just
Is Just
Substitute
Substitute
Simply A
Simply A
Remedy
Remedy
Pearles
Pearles
Far
Far
Being
Being
Before
Before
Consolidated
Consolidated
Has
Has
Bureau
Bureau
Since
Since
Throughout
Throughout
Tumblr Com
Tumblr Com
Associate
Associate
Bureau Of Labor Statistics
Bureau Of Labor Statistics
Does
Does
Which
Which
Farmers
Farmers
Prone
Prone
Manifesting
Manifesting
Manifested
Manifested
Also
Also
Do Not
Do Not
I Too
I Too
Replaced
Replaced
Had
Had
The Means
The Means
Replace
Replace
Have
Have
Are
Are
Advanced
Advanced
Cause
Cause
With
With
Forward
Forward
Had To
Had To
Fields
Fields
Machines
Machines
While
While
The Fact That
The Fact That
These
These
Becoming
Becoming
Very
Very
Means Of Production
Means Of Production
Many
Many
Take
Take
Your
Your
Correct
Correct
Experts
Experts
Buy
Buy
Sources
Sources
From
From
Not The
Not The
The Word
The Word
The
The
Consequences
Consequences
Obviously
Obviously
You Are
You Are
Where
Where
Tech
Tech
Not
Not
But
But
The Means Of Production
The Means Of Production
That
That
Simply
Simply
When
When
Both
Both
I Am A
I Am A
Loss
Loss
Progress
Progress
I Am
I Am
Other
Other
The Moment
The Moment
And
And
Universal
Universal
comfort
comfort
special
special
over
over
universal-basic-income
universal-basic-income
left-and-right
left-and-right
automatically
 automatically
intelligent
 intelligent
tumblr blog
 tumblr blog
robotics
 robotics
there is
 there is
changes
 changes
cheaper
 cheaper
already
 already
healthy
 healthy
large
 large
fang
 fang
said
 said
yet
 yet
left
 left
know
 know
come
 come
need
 need
hard
 hard
something
 something
growing
 growing
/tv/
 /tv/
no
 no
positive
 positive
through
through
fact
fact
too
too
extent
extent
there
there
benevolence
benevolence
lover
lover
labor
labor
claim
claim
my phone
my phone
consensus
consensus
manifest
manifest
efficient
efficient
assume
assume
usually
usually
separately
separately
go to
go to
their
their
assumption
assumption
subjective
subjective
unaware
unaware
needed
needed
i can
i can
seems
seems
hard working
hard working
debatable
debatable
i do
i do
do something
do something
those
those
happened
happened
sometimes
sometimes
might
might
slow
slow
feeling
feeling
afraid
afraid
error
error
because
because
hit
hit
then
then
though
though
everything
everything
just
just
misguided
misguided
disdain
disdain
likes
likes
humans
humans
people
people
always
always
nothing
nothing
making
making
this is
this is
right
right
great
great
done
done
political
political
this
this
more
more
income
income
look
look
scientific
scientific
happening
happening
prospect
prospect
in america
in america
href
href
use
use
economic
economic
reduction
reduction
aggregate
aggregate
massive
massive
obsolete
obsolete
companies
companies
industrial
industrial
basis
basis
products
products
semantics
semantics
social
social
machine
machine
for
for
made
made
times
times
what
what
birth
birth
post
post
cite
cite
the time
the time
luddite
luddite
now
now
system
system
you
you
new
new
moment
moment
they
they
make
make
projects
projects
all
all
move
move
them
them
own
own
think
think
will
will
lee
lee
believe
believe
means
means
guide
guide
intelligence
intelligence
etc
etc
techno
techno
fax
fax
amp
amp
basic
basic
anger
anger
fax machine
fax machine
case
case
degree
degree
closer
closer
sound
sound
one
one
switch
switch
artificial intelligence
artificial intelligence
extreme
extreme
can
can
ceo
ceo
creation
creation
who
who
class
class
data
data
step
step
pearl
pearl
com
com
rest
rest
working
working
human
human
job
job
rational
rational
Been
Been
Artificial
Artificial
Anti
Anti
All the Time
All the Time
All The
All The
Statistics
Statistics
Skepticism
Skepticism
Reality
Reality
Never
Never
Knowledge
Knowledge
Industrial Revolution
Industrial Revolution
Happiness
Happiness
Change
Change
Capitalist
Capitalist
Word
Word
What Is
What Is
Time
Time
Technology
Technology
Science
Science
Revolution
Revolution
Naive
Naive
Jobs
Jobs
Http
Http
History
History
Good
Good
Cracked
Cracked
Computer
Computer
Camera
Camera
Blog
Blog
Appreciate
Appreciate
Work
Work
tumblr
tumblr
True
True
Sorry
Sorry
shit
shit
Phone
Phone
iphone
iphone
Computers
Computers
cars
cars
America
America

Lee Fang @lhfang When roboticsdriverless cars replace 13 jobs in America and the political establishment does nothing 2016 anger will look minuscule 11516 1003 PM 287 RETWEETS 497 LIKES cracked-pearl-78 c-bassmeow Shit Luddites have been making this claim since the Industrial Revolution and they are no closer to being true While you are historically correct many economists tech experts people who work with tech who are far from luddites and even CEO’s of tech companies believe that with the increasing automation of jobs many jobs will go to machines and there will be a great massive reduction in jobs Economists both from the left and right think this is to be true since it’s already happening just not to a large extent YET Even the Bureau of labor statistics projects massive job loss due to human jobs becoming obsolete because technological changes that make it more efficient to replace humans with machinescomputers since it will be cheaper less error and more efficient to replace humans since machines do not need to rest do not have families can be worked to their extreme and can be programmed to do something correctly all the time Moreover with the prospect of artificial intelligence which is being invested heavily the change might manifest more rapidly One remedy for this from some economists from both the left and right is to enact a universal basic income But while I appreciate your skepticism which is very healthy because i too have a disdain for predictions with no basis in reality or that sound alarmist- to my knowledge there seems to be a slow growing consensus from many fields that technological progress will replace many many human jobs the extent to which they will replace them is obviously debatable but the fact that they will be replaced to some degree that affects us seems to not be I’m sorry I can’t cite sources I’m on my phone at the momentAlso throughout history technological progress has always replaced jobs There are less shoemakers now farmers cashiers and countless other positions due to technological progress Historically though we have been able to replace these jobs with new ones created through social change technological change and other factors but I and many think that we have hit a special time in history where technology will simply take over many more jobs than we can replace Technological progress is so advanced now that many products that we had to buy separately are now consolidated into one an iphone is a fax machine a phone a computer a camera a tv etc and at times less people are needed in the aggregate to make these products Lastly and this is just semantics I do believe that many techno-optimists believe technological progress automatically means “good” because we associate the word technology with human advancement and because “progress” is a word that assumes benevolence but this is not the case Technological and scientific progress are not inherently good I am no luddite and I am a lover of science BUT science and technological advancement are sometimes removed and unaware of the unintended consequences created by their advancement since we rarely know all the social economic political ramifications brought by said technologyscientific discoveries at the time of their creation and birth So to assume everything will be a positive step forward is a naive assumption not supported by data but simply a subjective feeling of comfort and happiness because tech progress is being made So i am no luddite but I do think there is cause this time to be healthily afraid of what is to come A capitalist system has historically relied on humans but when those who own the means of production switch to a more inexpensive rational hard working and anti-error prone substitute … then what happens? It has never been done before so to assume you can use history as a guide which is usually a very intelligent move is somewhat misguided for what is to come has never happened before Meme

found @ 30 likes ON 2019-03-10 05:18:33 BY ME.ME

source: tumblr